The dissent authored by Justice Anita Earls presents a sharp contrast. (The court typically has a 5–2 conservative majority, but with Riggs recused, Earls is the only liberal sitting for this case ...
However, the court, which has a 5–1 Republican majority with Riggs recused, may be deadlocked on how to ultimately decide the case. Republican Justice Trey Allen, who once clerked for Newby ...